top of page

Does America Deserve Trump?


As America stands at a pivotal crossroads, a haunting question screams out: Has America lost its moral compass? The parallels with the decline of the Roman Empire and the societal upheaval in the 1930s and 1940s in Germany are not just historical curiosities; they are stark reminders of what could happen to a superpower that loses its way.

The Fall of Rome: A Mirror to Modern America

Once invincible and majestic, the Roman Empire crumbled under corruption, economic disparity, and moral decay. Today, America faces similar challenges.

  • Political corruption is rampant.

  • The gap between rich and poor widens.

  • Societal values are in a constant state of flux.

The American Dream, once a beacon of hope and opportunity, is now an American nightmare that flickers in the shadow of these towering issues.

Echoes of Germany: Radicalization and Alternative Realities

Germany's radicalization and societal transformation in the 30s and 40s are a chilling reminder of how quickly a nation can be led astray. In America, the polarisation of politics and the proliferation of a 'parallel universe' of facts create an environment where truth becomes subjective and empathy a scarce commodity. The rise in radical ideologies and the diminishing space for moderate, balanced discourse are symptomatic of a society struggling to find its moral grounding.

The Lobby System: Undermining Democracy

The influence of the lobby system in American politics is a critical factor in understanding the current state of democracy. This system, where various industries exert significant influence over policy decisions, has profound implications for domestic and foreign policy, often prioritising corporate interests over public welfare.

The Military-Industrial Complex

  • The military-industrial complex plays a pivotal role in shaping U.S. foreign policy. This sector's lobbying efforts have been linked to the perpetuation of military conflicts and the destabilisation of regions, serving the dual purpose of testing new weapons and creating markets for arms sales.

  • These lobbying efforts often influence government overthrows and interventions in foreign countries, aiming to install regimes favourable to American defence contractors. This self-interested approach can lead to long-term global instability and human suffering.

Big Pharma's Influence

  • The pharmaceutical industry exerts considerable influence on healthcare policies. This influence is often geared towards protecting patents, suppressing generic drug competition, and influencing drug pricing policies, frequently resulting in higher drug costs for consumers.

  • Big Pharma's lobbying efforts have also impacted pharmaceutical regulation, sometimes leading to delayed or insufficient regulation of drugs with public health implications.

The Oil Industry and Environmental Policies

  • The oil and gas industry's lobbying efforts have significantly impacted environmental policies. These industries have historically resisted regulations to reduce carbon emissions, protect natural resources, and promote renewable energy.

  • Their influence has contributed to a slower response to climate change, often prioritising short-term economic gains over long-term environmental sustainability and public health.

Big Tech's Growing Power

  • The rise of Big Tech companies has introduced a new dynamic in lobbying. Their influence extends to privacy, data protection, and antitrust regulations.

  • Big Tech's lobbying efforts often aim to shape policies in a way that consolidates their market dominance, impacting competition and consumer rights.

Implications on Democracy

  • The overarching impact of these industries on American policy-making raises concerns about the health of the democratic process. When corporate lobbying dictates policy, the interests of the general public can be sidelined.

  • This dynamic can lead to a governance system where policies reflect the will of the wealthiest and most powerful rather than the collective will of the electorate.

The Need for Reform

Addressing the outsized influence of lobbying in American politics is essential for restoring democratic integrity. This involves campaign finance reform, greater transparency in lobbying activities, and stricter regulations on the revolving door between public office and private sector lobbying.

A Call for Public Engagement

Public awareness and engagement are crucial in countering the disproportionate influence of these industries. Citizen activism, informed voting and support for policies that limit lobbying excesses are vital in reclaiming democracy from corporate interests.

In conclusion, the lobby system in its current form presents a significant threat to democratic ideals in the United States. The influence of industries like the military-industrial complex, Big Pharma, the oil industry, and Big Tech extends far beyond mere policy shaping; it fundamentally alters the landscape of American politics, often at the expense of public interest and global stability. A concerted effort towards reform and increased public vigilance is essential to ensure that democracy serves the many, not just the few.

A Divided Society: The Rich and the Rest

In exploring the chasm between the rich and the rest in America, it is essential to understand how this economic disparity reflects a deeper societal divide. The stark contrast in living standards, access to resources, and opportunities for advancement paints a picture of almost two different Americas living side by side.

The Wealth Gap and Its Historical Roots

  • The current wealth gap in the U.S. is not a new phenomenon but the result of decades of economic policies and practices. Tax structures, wage disparities, and a shift from manufacturing to a service-based economy have all played roles in widening this gap.

  • Historical practices like redlining and discriminatory lending have long-lasting effects, particularly on minority communities, contributing to generational wealth disparities.

Impact of Technology and Globalisation

  • The rise of technology and globalisation has created immense wealth for those at the top, particularly in sectors like tech and finance. However, it has also led to job displacement and wage stagnation for middle- and lower-income workers.

  • This disparity is not just economic; it also translates into differing access to technology and the digital world, further entrenching the divide.

Education and Opportunity

  • Education, once a great equaliser, has become another area of division. The soaring costs of higher education and the growing importance of elite networking opportunities mean that higher education often reinforces existing inequalities rather than mitigating them.

  • The quality of primary and secondary education varies greatly depending on the wealth of the community, leading to disparities in educational outcomes and future opportunities.

Healthcare Disparities

  • Healthcare in America is deeply intertwined with economic status. The wealthy can access the best care, while the poor often struggle to afford essential health services. This disparity has been starkly highlighted during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Housing and Living Conditions

The housing market reflects and exacerbates the wealth divide. In many cities, gentrification and rising housing costs have pushed lower-income families to less desirable areas, often with limited resources and opportunities.

The Psychological and Social Impact

The divide between rich and poor also has significant psychological and social impacts. People who feel left behind by the economic system may experience alienation, hopelessness, and resentment.

The wealthy, living in their enclaves, can become disconnected from the realities of most of the population, leading to a lack of empathy and understanding across socio-economic divides.

Political Implications

  • Economic disparity often translates into political disparity. The wealthy have greater means to influence political decisions through donations and lobbying, perpetuating a system that favours their interests.

  • This dynamic undermines the democratic principle of equal representation, leading to policies that often prioritise the needs of the wealthy over those of the broader population.

The division between the rich and the rest in America is more than an economic issue; it is a fundamental challenge to the nation's social fabric and democratic values. Addressing this divide requires comprehensive reforms in taxation, education, healthcare, and housing policies. It also necessitates a cultural shift towards empathy and understanding, bridging the gap economically and in terms of social cohesion and shared values.

The path forward must involve creating opportunities for all, ensuring that the American Dream is not reserved for a privileged few but is a genuine possibility for every citizen. This requires a commitment to policies that promote equitable growth, support small businesses, invest in education and healthcare, and ensure fair wages and working conditions.

Furthermore, there needs to be a concerted effort to foster community and connection across economic lines. Initiatives that encourage dialogue and interaction between different socio-economic groups can help break down barriers and dispel stereotypes. Community programmes, inclusive urban planning, and policies encouraging mixed-income neighbourhoods can all play a role.

In conclusion, the divide between the rich and the rest in America is a deep-seated issue with far-reaching implications. It challenges the nation's core values of equality and opportunity. Addressing this divide is not just an economic imperative but a moral one. It calls for reevaluating societal priorities and a renewed commitment to the principles of justice and equity that have long been touted as the foundation of American society. Only then can America begin to mend its frayed social fabric and move towards a future where prosperity and opportunity are accessible to all.

Leadership and the People's Will

The leadership of Donald Trump represents a unique and controversial chapter in American politics, marked by a series of allegations related to corruption, legal challenges, and a distinct style of communication often criticized for promoting falsehoods. His influence on the American political landscape raises profound questions about the intersection of leadership, the people's will, and the state of democracy.

Corruption Allegations and Legal Challenges

Numerous allegations of corruption have clouded Donald Trump's presidency and post-presidency period. These include conflicts of interest related to his business dealings, accusations of tax fraud, and potential violations of campaign finance laws. The multitude of civil and criminal cases pending against Trump reflect a deeply concerning aspect of his leadership. They raise legal and ethical questions, challenging the norms and expectations of presidential conduct.

A Wall of Lies

One of the most defining aspects of Trump's leadership has been his relationship with the truth. Fact-checkers have documented thousands of false or misleading claims made during his presidency. This consistent spread of misinformation has not only impacted domestic politics but has also had ramifications on the global stage, affecting international relations and America's credibility abroad.

The Question of Leaving Office

The speculation about whether Trump would peacefully transfer power if he lost an election became a significant concern, especially towards the end of his first term. The events leading up to the 2020 election, culminating in the Capitol riot on January 6, brought attention to this issue. The notion of Trump refusing to leave office taps into deeper fears about the erosion of democratic norms and the potential for authoritarianism in American politics.

The Prospect of Ivanka Trump

Because of her involvement in her father's administration and public persona, there is speculation that Ivanka Trump might become the first female president. Such a scenario raises questions about political dynasties, the role of celebrity in politics, and the nature of democratic selection in the U.S. It also speaks to the polarised state of American politics, where the appeal of a candidate may hinge more on their family name and celebrity status than on their political experience or policies.

Implications for Democracy

The phenomenon surrounding Donald Trump—from his contentious leadership style to the loyalty he commands among his supporters—points to a deeply divided America. It underscores the challenges in balancing charismatic leadership with democratic principles and the rule of law. Trump's influence on American politics illustrates how charismatic leadership can mobilise a significant portion of the electorate, even in the face of controversy and legal challenges. This mobilisation raises critical questions about the nature of the people's will and its expression in a democratic society.

A Call for Reflection and Vigilance

Despite numerous controversies, the ongoing influence of Trump in American politics is a call for reflection on the state of democracy in the U.S. It emphasises the need for vigilance against the erosion of democratic norms and the importance of holding leaders accountable. It also highlights the necessity for a well-informed electorate capable of discerning facts from misinformation, a critical factor in ensuring that leadership and the people will align with democratic principles and ethical governance.

In summary, the leadership of Donald Trump, marked by allegations of corruption, a propensity for spreading misinformation, and his impact on democratic norms, presents a complex case study in American politics. It challenges traditional notions of presidential conduct and raises important questions about the future direction of U.S. democracy. The continued influence and potential political aspirations within the Trump family, including Ivanka Trump, add another dimension to this scenario, reflecting the intersection of celebrity, politics, and the American presidency. As the nation grapples with these issues, the need for critical examination of leadership qualities, adherence to democratic principles, and the role of public scrutiny in holding leaders accountable becomes increasingly apparent.

Public Perception and the Role of Education: Addressing the "Dumb or Dumber" Dilemma

The state of public perception and the role of education in the United States are critical factors in shaping the nation’s future. The current situation, often perceived as a choice between 'dumb and dumber', reflects systemic issues in the American education system and the broader societal narrative. Significant changes in these areas are imperative to foster a more informed, critical, and globally aware citizenry.

Rethinking Education: Beyond Isolationism

American education has often been criticised for its isolationist approach, focusing primarily on American exceptionalism and less on global perspectives. This approach can limit students' understanding of the world and America's place, hindering their ability to think critically about global issues. Incorporating a more global curriculum that emphasises international history, cultures, and current global challenges is essential. Such an approach would help students develop a more nuanced understanding of the world and America's role within it.

Questioning the Narrative of Unquestioned Greatness

The narrative that "America is great" and the military is this awesome, omnipresent force for good often goes unchallenged in educational settings, leading to a one-dimensional view of national identity and history. This narrative can overshadow complex historical realities and ethical considerations. Education should encourage critical thinking and a balanced understanding of history, including achievements and shortcomings. This balanced approach is crucial for fostering a more informed and reflective citizenry.

The Pledge of Allegiance: Patriotism or Indoctrination?

The practice of reciting the Pledge of Allegiance in schools has been a subject of debate, with some viewing it as a form of false patriotism and indoctrination. Critics argue that it promotes a narrow, unexamined form of nationalism at an early age. Reconsidering this practice could involve promoting a broader understanding of patriotism that encourages critical engagement with civic values and the complexities of national identity rather than unquestioned loyalty.

The Need for Educational Reform

To address the 'dumb or dumber' dilemma, educational reform is necessary. This includes investing in teacher training, updating curriculums to include critical thinking and media literacy, and ensuring that education is accessible and equitable for all students. Education should be a tool for empowerment, not just a means to instill a particular nationalistic viewpoint. This involves teaching students to question, analyse, and form informed opinions.

Encouraging Media Literacy and Critical Thinking

In the age of information overload and misinformation, media literacy is crucial. Students must be taught to evaluate sources critically, understand the difference between facts and opinions, and discern biases in media and political rhetoric. Critical thinking skills are essential for navigating modern society's complexities and participating effectively in democratic processes.

A Call to Action

The current state of public perception and education calls for action from policymakers, educators, and the community. It requires a collective effort to transform the educational landscape into one that truly prepares students for the challenges of the 21st century. This transformation must be guided by a commitment to truth, critical inquiry, and a global perspective, moving beyond narrow definitions of patriotism and greatness.

In conclusion, addressing the perceived choice between 'dumb and dumber' in America involves a fundamental reevaluation of educational practices and societal narratives. By fostering a more critical, globally aware, and ethically engaged form of education, the nation can cultivate a citizenry capable of thoughtful participation in the global community and the democratic process. This shift is not just about changing curricula but about reimagining the role of education in shaping a more informed, responsible, and reflective society.


As we witness what might be the twilight of the American Empire, the parallels with the past are not just cautionary tales; they are urgent wake-up calls. The moral decay, societal division, and political corruption we see today are symptoms of deeper issues that must be addressed.

America is at a juncture where the choices made today will determine its future, much like the decisions that sealed the fates of the Roman Empire and Nazi Germany. The warning signs are clear: unchecked political corruption, rampant economic inequality, societal polarisation, and the erosion of democratic values. If these issues continue to fester, America risks following the same path of decline that befell once-great civilizations.

A Warning to America: Change Course Now

The situation is reminiscent of the climate crisis: actions taken now might already be too late, but inaction guarantees disaster. America's moral compass needs recalibrating, which involves a collective effort from all sectors of society. It's time for political leaders to prioritise the nation's long-term health over short-term gains and partisan politics. Businesses must adopt ethical practices that contribute to societal well-being rather than solely focusing on profits. The media and educational institutions must champion the truth and foster critical thinking.

As individuals, Americans must engage in informed and constructive discourse, moving beyond the echo chambers that polarise and divide. It's crucial to rebuild a sense of community and shared purpose, emphasising empathy, understanding, and respect for differing viewpoints.

The ultimate demise of the American Empire is not an inevitability; it's a possibility that can be averted. But this requires a conscious and concerted effort to steer the nation back towards a path of moral integrity, social justice, and democratic principles. The lessons of history are clear: empires and societies fall when they lose sight of these values. America must heed these lessons and act decisively to change course or risk witnessing the end of its era as a global leader and beacon of democratic ideals.

America stands at a crossroads. The choice is stark: continue down the current path and face the consequences, or embrace change and work towards a future that upholds the true values of democracy and freedom. The world is watching, and history will remember the decisions made at this critical moment.

1648 | Beyond Consulting

We help transform and future-proof financial firms. 1648 is at the forefront of today's rapidly evolving financial landscape, guiding wealth managers and fintech firms through discovery and transformational journeys. Our expertise ensures that these firms adapt to industry transformation and drive it forward by employing the most effective strategies and digital innovations. The future of wealth management becomes more transparent, intelligent, and resilient with 1648.

The strategies presented are thematic and do not constitute investment advice (or advice of any kind). No assurance can be given that the objectives of the investment strategies above will be achieved; the strategies involve risk (including, without limitation, illiquidity risk) and may incur a loss on some or all capital deployed. The opinions expressed, or indeed, the information or assumptions that underpin them, may contain errors, mistakes, or omissions; no assurance or warranty can be made as to the accuracy or completeness of this information, and readers should not place any reliance on this content to execute investment decisions or for any other purpose. Readers accept full responsibility for using this content and are kindly requested to consult with their professional advisor before making any investment decision related to the same.

Please find below a range of custom GTPs to support research and discovery:

4 views0 comments


bottom of page